Monday, January 12, 2026 / by Ryan Huemmer
Cottage Grove, WI Housing Market: 2024 vs. 2025 Year-Over-Year Breakdown
What buyers and sellers need to know heading into 2026
If you’re thinking about buying or selling a home in Cottage Grove, Wisconsin in 2026, understanding how the market shifted over the last year is critical. Below is a clear, data-backed comparison of 2024 vs. 2025 for single-family homes and condos.
Big Picture: The Market Picked Up Speed in 2025
Across all property types, 2025 showed stronger demand, higher prices, and longer timelines, signaling a more competitive and value-driven market compared to 2024.
All Properties
Homes Sold:
2024: 119
2025: 149 (+25% YoY)
Median Sale Price:
2024: $450,000
2025: $497,500 (+10.6% YoY)
Average Days on Market (DOM):
2024: 28 days
2025: 43 days
Translation: More homes sold at higher prices, but buyers took more time to make decisions.
Single-Family Homes: Prices Rose, Pace Slowed
Single-family homes remain the dominant and most in-demand pr ...
Read More
the huemmer home team, real estate agent, wi, lpt realty, buying a home, housing market, selling a home, best real estate agent, cottage grove, wi housing market update
Thursday, December 11, 2025 / by Ryan Huemmer
Client Love Spotlight!
We are so grateful for incredible clients who take the time to share their experience, especially when it highlights the rockstars on our team!
Huge shoutout to Jenna Paez, who continues to raise the bar in real estate.
“Jenna is the most amazing realtor! She is incredibly knowledgeable, makes you feel completely comfortable, and is responsive to every question. She ensured every detail was taken care of and helped me find an amazing home in Cottage Grove. I cannot recommend her enough!”
Jenna - your dedication, care, and expertise make all the difference.
If you’re thinking about buying or selling, get the level of service you truly deserve.
Contact The Huemmer Home Team today and work with the best!
...
Read More
the huemmer home team, real estate agent, realtor, lpt realty, buying a home, cottage grove, top realtor, wi real estate
Friday, September 26, 2025 / by Ryan Huemmer
At The Huemmer Home Team, we’ve been keeping a close eye on the Cottage Grove, WI housing market, and as we move into fall 2025, the numbers continue to show strength. The median sale price for homes in our area is currently sitting around $510,000, up more than 6% from this time last year. Listing prices are trending even higher, averaging about $559,400, with new construction pushing values upward. On average, homes in Cottage Grove are valued at just over $465,000, which is a 2.6% increase compared to last year. What really stands out is that homes are selling faster, median days on market has dropped to 49, down from 67 in 2024 and closed sales in August jumped to 12, compared to just 7 during the same month last year. With inventory still limited, well-presented homes in desirable neighborhoods are attracting strong attention and often multiple offers.
Of course, mortgage rates remain a major talking point. The Huemmer Home Team has an advantage with a f ...
Read More
the huemmer home team, real estate agent, ryan huemmer, cottage grove, wi housing market update, cottage grove wi homes for sale
Friday, November 10, 2023 / by Ryan Huemmer
"This home purchase was a difficult, transitional move, for so many reasons. I am and will forever be grateful to Jenna Paez for the patience, kindness and compassion shown to me throughout; God knows it wasn’t always easy. Thank you, thank you, thank you for your reliably knowledgeable guidance, especially in during the countless times I was floundering."
The Huemmer Home Team
RE/MAX Preferred
Jenna Paez
jenna@thhtrealty.com
www.madisonareahomesforsale.com ...
Read More
the huemmer home team, re/max, realtor, wi, real estate agent, madison, madisonareahomesforsale.com, selling a home, cottage grove, best realtor, best real estate agent, jenna paez, top real estate agent, top realtor
Wednesday, November 8, 2023 / by Ryan Huemmer
"Our experience selling our home with Amber and THHT was nothing but positive. Communication, marketing, staging and using the app to schedule showings made the whole process seamless. Having the use of the truck was super convenient for our move. We highly recommend The Huemmer Home Team!!"
The Huemmer Home Team
RE/MAX Preferred
Amber Huemmer
608-279-5424
www.madisonareahomesforsale.com
Read More
the huemmer home team, re/max, wi, realtor, real estate agent, amber huemmer, 6082795424, madison, madisonareahomesforsale.com, selling a home, cottage grove
