If you need assistance, please call 608-279-5424

Why Americans Believe Housing Costs Are Too High; And They're Wrong

Monday, October 13, 2025   /   by Ryan Huemmer

Why Americans Believe Housing Costs Are Too High; And They're Wrong

A recent survey shows that nearly all Americans agree: housing in the U.S. is too expensive. Only 3% of respondents believe housing costs are “reasonable”, while a staggering 93% say prices are too high, with 43% calling them “way too high.”
 


These perceptions come amid a housing market where affordability is near four-decade lows relative to income, and roughly half of renter households are cost-burdened, paying more than 30% of their income on housing.

What Americans Blame for High Housing Costs

The survey revealed Americans are divided on the cause of the housing crisis. Here’s a breakdown of what respondents think is driving up costs:

Investors buying homes for profit: 48%
High cost of building materials: 46%
Greedy landlords charging high rents: 43%
Elected officials not prioritizing affordable housing: 33%
Immigration: 17%
Length of time to build new homes: 9%


Interestingly, while investors often get the spotlight in public debates, economists argue their role in rising housing costs is limited.

The Real Culprit: A Housing Shortage & Low Interest Rates

Most housing economists agree that the fundamental problem is a chronic shortage of housing. The U.S. needs nearly 4 million additional homes to meet current demand. Factors like rising construction costs, zoning restrictions, and red tape in permitting processes all contribute to this shortage. 
 
Ryan Huemmer with The Huemmer Home Team believes the issue is interest rates. "Interest rates are the real issue with slightly over 50% of all mortgage holders under 3.5% on a 30 year fixed. The largest buyer pool, year over year, is existing homeowners. Until they decide to upsize, downsize or just sell, they are locking up existing homes from being listed and sold. New home construction costs are too high, so we have to get our existing supply on the market. Also people don't buy because of the cost, they don't buy because of the payment." 
 
Data shows 2024 was the lowest year for existing home sales since 1995. Though that doesn't tell the whole story. We have 78 million more people in the US than 1995, equating to more buyer demand. The average first-time homebuyer age is now 38 years old, an all-time high. Creating a real estate storm for Generation X, Millennials and Generation Z homebuyers to battle over housing.

Americans feel the pinch of high housing costs. Understanding the root causes helps buyers, sellers, and policymakers navigate today’s challenging market.
 
The Huemmer Home Team
LPT Realty

  the huemmer home team, real estate agent, lpt realty, housing market, mortgage rates, ryan huemmer