Monday, October 19, 2026 / by Ryan Huemmer
Dane County Housing Report - October Newsletter
Dane County Housing Market Update: What September 2026 Sales Mean for Buyers and Sellers
September brought 524 single-family and condominium closings across Dane County, down 19% from 646 in August. That drop is the normal seasonal shift into the fall market, with fewer buyers and sellers active as the year winds down. What did not drop was price. The median sale price for all homes came in at $474,950, essentially flat from August’s $475,000, and homes took just one extra day to sell, with a median of 12 days on market.

The single-family market actually got a little stronger. The median single-family sale price rose 1.8% to $508,950, up from $499,900 in August. Of the 422 single-family homes that closed, 44% sold in seven days or less and 25% drew competing offers, the exact same rate as August. The average single-family sale was $582,535, and the median price per square foot was $247. Condos held steady as well, with 102 closings at a median price of $340,500, a slight 0.4% dip from August’s $342,000. Condos took longer to sell, with a median of 20.5 days on market, and only 14% drew multiple offers.
Complete newsletter - Here
The $400,000 to $500,000 range remained the busiest part of the single-family market with 113 closings. Another 78 homes sold between $500,000 and $600,000, 72 sold between $300,000 and $400,000, 68 sold between $600,000 and $750,000, and 73 sold at $750,000 or higher. Only 18 single-family homes sold under $300,000. One in three single-family closings came in at $600,000 or more, the same share as August, which shows the upper end of the market did not slow down with the season.
Location continues to drive price more than any other factor. Madison led the county with 209 closings at a median of $430,000 and a median of 10 days on market. Sun Prairie recorded 50 sales at a median of $446,750, and Cottage Grove had 17 sales at a median of $450,000. Waunakee posted the highest median among the larger communities at $616,000, while Monona topped the list overall at $728,000 on five sales. Middleton came in at $547,500, Verona at $544,000, Fitchburg at $550,000, and Windsor at $552,250. Verona and McFarland were the fastest markets in the county, with homes going under contract in a median of just four days. Cottage Grove and Sun Prairie are the tightest on inventory, each with less than a month and a half of supply.
Looking at what is for sale right now, there are 1,375 active single-family and condo listings in Dane County, made up of 981 single-family homes and 394 condos. The median list price for single-family homes is $529,900, and single-family supply sits at 2.3 months, which still favors sellers. Condo supply is higher at 3.9 months. Active listings have a median of 53 days on market, and with 30-year fixed mortgage rates now at 7.50%, that number is climbing and some leverage is shifting toward buyers.
The most important story in this data is the gap between what is listed and what is actually selling. The median single-family list price is $529,900, but the median single-family sale was $508,950. On top of that, 423 active listings, nearly a third of everything on the market, have been sitting for more than 90 days. Most of those are homes that launched at a price above what buyers were willing to pay.
For sellers, the fall market still rewards the right price. With 44% of single-family homes selling in a week or less, a well-priced home can move just as fast as it would in summer. The sellers who struggle are the ones who price their home based on what a neighbor listed for instead of what a neighbor actually sold for. If you are ready to sell, there is no reason to wait for spring. Fewer homes will come on the market over the next three months, and the buyers still shopping now are serious. If your home has already been sitting, the market is telling you something. A price adjustment or a fresh relaunch with better photos and preparation is usually what gets a stale listing moving again.
For buyers, fall is the window for leverage. With a median of 53 days on market for active listings and nearly a third of inventory sitting for three months or longer, many sellers are ready to negotiate. That said, the best-priced homes are still selling in days, especially under $400,000 and in Verona, McFarland, Cottage Grove, and Sun Prairie. Having a full pre-approval in hand before you start touring is still the difference between winning a home and watching someone else get it. Condos are the most negotiable segment of the market right now, with nearly four months of supply, a 20-day median to sell, and competing offers only 14% of the time. Keep in mind that the median association fee on September condo sales was $323 a month, so build that into your payment comparison.
The Huemmer Home Team brings a rare combination of lending, investing, and construction experience to every transaction. Before earning his real estate license in 2016, Ryan Huemmer spent more than 13 years in mortgage lending, structuring financing and learning exactly what it takes to get a deal to the closing table. He also owns and manages a portfolio of 26 rental units and has designed and built three homes from the ground up. Together, the team has closed more than 2,200 transactions. If you are buying, selling, or investing in Dane County or anywhere in South Central Wisconsin, reach out to The Huemmer Home Team to talk through what this market means for your plans.


